| Edward Burger | 2013-2020 |
| Jake B. Schrum | 2000-2013 |
| Roy B. Shilling, Jr. | 1981-2000 |
| Lawrence Durwood Fleming | 1961-1981 |
| William Carrington Finch | 1949-1961 |
| John Nelson Russel Score | 1942-1949 |
| John William Bergin | 1935-1941 |
| King Vivion | 1928-1935 |
| James Samuel Barcus | 1924-1928 |
| Paul Whitfield Horn | 1922-1924 |
| Charles McTyeire Bishop | 1911-1922 |
| Robert Stewart Hyer | 1898-1911 |
| John H. McLean | 1891-1897 |
| John Wesley Heidt | 1885-1889 |
| Francis Asbury Mood | 1873-1884 |
Soule University (1856)
| Francis Asbury Mood | 1868-1873 |
| William Halsey | 1861-1868 |
| George W. Carter | 1860-1861 |
| William Halsey | 1856-1860 |
McKenzie College (1848)
|
John McKenzie |
1848-1868 |
| F. H. Blades | 1846-1847 |
Wesleyan College (1844)
| Lester Janes | 1844-1846 |
Rutersville College (1840)
| Chauncey Richardson |
1840-1846 |
|
William Halsey |
1846-1856 |